The 19th, early 20th, and mid 20th have their wires crossed, so the game assigns the wrong AIM settings to the pitchers–which pretty much screws up replays.
To get the proper AIM settings (until the fix is published):
- Late 20th is OK
- Mid 20th – Select 19th Century
- Early 20th – Select Mid 20th
- 19th Century – Select Early 20th